The Opening Drive 5/6: No Team Knows the Supplemental Draft Quite Like Cleveland

The Browns built an entire era of football on a loophole. Now, with another talented quarterback's eligibility in jeopardy, they're being asked the same question they've answered before.

May 07, 2026

∙ Paid

CLEVELAND - 1985: Quarterback Bernie Kosar of the Cleveland Browns looks on from the field before a National Football League game at Municipal Stadium circa 1985 in Cleveland, Ohio. (Photo by George Gojkovich/Getty Images)

There is a particular kind of Cleveland Browns fan who hears the words “supplemental draft” and has a complex and involuntary reaction. Not quite dread. Not quite hope. Something in between — the somatic memory of the highest of highs and the most operatic of what-ifs. Forty years of supplemental draft history has given this franchise one of its most beloved players and one of its most haunting coulda-beens. Now, as Brendan Sorsby’s NCAA eligibility hangs in the balance, he threatens to reopen that complicated chapter.

The questions swirling around Sorsby — his gambling investigation, his future eligibility, his real talent level — are real and serious. But before we get to him, let’s remember exactly why this team and this particular draft mechanism have such a loaded history.

Football: Cleveland Browns QB Bernie Kosar (19) in action, pass vs Cincinnati Bengals at Cleveland Municipal Stadium. Cleveland, OH 9/5/1993 CREDIT: Damian Strohmeyer (Photo by Damian Strohmeyer /Sports Illustrated via Getty Images)

Bernie Kosar — QB, 1st Round — (1985)

The original and most audacious. The Boardman, Ohio native who had led Miami to a national championship, Kosar engineered one of the most brazen maneuvers in NFL draft history: deliberately not submitting his paperwork for the regular draft, then declaring for the supplemental. The Browns traded multiple picks to the Bills to acquire the top supplemental selection, outfoxed the Vikings and Oilers, and landed their hometown franchise quarterback. He would take Cleveland to three AFC Championship Games in five years, and remains the last Browns QB to reach that stage.

BEREA, OH - APRIL 21, 2016: Wide receiver Terrelle Pryor #11 of the Cleveland Browns runs a route during a voluntary mini camp on April 21, 2016 at the Cleveland Browns training facility in Berea, Ohio. (Photo by Nick Cammett/Diamond Images/Getty Images)

Terrelle Pryor — QB/WR (via Oakland), 3rd Round — (2011)

Not a Brown at the time of his supplemental selection — that was the Raiders — but Pryor eventually found his way to Cleveland, where in 2016 he reinvented himself as a wide receiver and put up over 1,000 yards. A local Ohio State product whose conversion from quarterback to wideout gave the Browns a genuine weapon in an otherwise bleak season.

CLEVELAND, OH - OCTOBER 28: Wide receiver Josh Gordon #13 of the Cleveland Browns runs against the San Diego Chargers during the second half at Cleveland Browns Stadium on October 28, 2012 in Cleveland, Ohio. The Browns defeated the Chargers 7-6. (Photo by Jason Miller/Getty Images)

Josh Gordon — WR, 2nd Round — (2012)

The most tantalizing and heartbreaking of them all. Suspended at Baylor for a failed drug test, Gordon cost Cleveland a second-round pick. He repaid it almost immediately — 805 yards as a rookie, then a league-leading 1,646 yards in 2013, including back-to-back 200-yard games. He looked like a generational receiver at 22. The rest, as every Browns fan knows, is a saga of suspensions and second chances that never quite resolved itself into the career it should have been.

Below you’ll find the latest in the BFB catalog for supporters to dig into. Click the link to become a supporter if you haven’t already, and enjoy all the latest from Browns Film Breakdown.

Latest Podcasts:

Latest Articles:

Latest Film Rooms:

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to Browns Film Breakdown to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.